Orbital answers futility with persistence.' Discuss.
A high-scoring Text Response essay, annotated
A high-scoring Text Response essay on Samantha Harvey's Orbital, annotated to demonstrate analytical craft and essay structure.
Orbital answers futility with persistence.' Discuss.
Published in 2023 amidst an intensifying recognition of the Anthropocene and the accelerating climate crisis, Samantha Harvey's novel Orbital surveys the precariousness of mortal existence against the staggering immensity of the cosmos, interrogating whether human action holds meaning against inevitable cosmic erasure.1 While the vast expanse of the void initially frames earthly striving as an exercise in futility, the novel ultimately reveals that the disciplined routines and shared witness of the crew transform apparent meaninglessness into a quiet defiance, locating deep value within human endurance itself.2 Harvey therefore challenges her modern audience to abandon the despair that cosmic insignificance invites, urging contemporary readers to embrace resilience as its own justification in an indifferent universe.3
Harvey initially presents the overwhelming scale of the cosmos as a confrontation with futility, yet reveals that shared witness transforms human vulnerability into an enduring resilience.4 Suspended in liminal space with the collective consciousness "they are so together"5 yet "so alone", Harvey's illustration of collectivity coalesces the crew into a unified psychological entity as the isolating sublimity of the void forges an interdependence that steels them against cosmic meaninglessness. Centring on the fragmented "trail of gunpowder" that projects a "milky cover" obscuring their "siphoning eye", the roving narration drains the astronauts and cosmonauts of perspectives that scatter into space's boundless immensity, exposing the apparent pointlessness of human observation. Thus, to resist such cosmic erasure, readers bear witness to Shaun's "postcard of Las Meninas", reflective of mere bystanders, mirroring their "privileged anxious view" of "mother Earth", recasting the act of watching as a form of steadfast continuation. By means of this contemplation, the image articulates the duality between beauty and burden as the readership alongside the crew experience Earth's Anthropocene transformation, refusing the despair that helplessness invites. This collective steadfastness narrows into the intimate weight of mortality when Chie's bereavement exposes the fragile limits of human agency.6 Through Chie's anguished chant "mother mother mother mother"7, the narration captures the introspective burden of individual loss, inviting readers to childishly echo the mantra in their own minds and revealing how mourning is endured rather than escaped. Against this sorrow, the storm's "building magnificence" held alongside Pietro's fixation on the "particular fisherman and his family" alchemises the typhoon's immensity into a meditation on shared vulnerability, serving as a microcosm of solidarity against an indifferent world. Hence, the oxymoronic enchantment of an "unearthly watery light" residing from the typhoon magnifies the "tethers of biological life" as the chapel's sanctified nature outlasts the "piddling speck" of earthly existence, elevating survival into an act of persistence. Through the convergence of shared watching with collective mourning, Harvey establishes that human steadfastness persists despite cosmic indifference. Harvey initially presents the overwhelming scale of the cosmos as a confrontation with futility, yet reveals that shared witness transforms human vulnerability into an enduring resilience.8
Want to tailor your essays to your teachers while preparing for the VCE exam?
Our VCE English tutors show you how to adapt your writing for your school's markers while getting exam ready, using the exact techniques annotated here. Join the waitlist to secure a spot.
Join the waitlist