Artin Education
Annotated Sample Essay Text Response AI Assisted

Ultimately, Orbital urges readers to appreciate human achievement. Do you agree?

A high-scoring Text Response essay, annotated

Orbital · Samantha Harvey

A high-scoring Text Response essay on Samantha Harvey's Orbital, annotated to demonstrate analytical craft and essay structure.

Essay prompt

Ultimately, Orbital urges readers to appreciate human achievement. Do you agree?

VCE EnglishOrbitalSamantha HarveyText Response

Published in 2023 amidst pandemic confinement1, Samantha Harvey's novel Orbital surveys an Earth altered by the Anthropocene across sixteen circuits of the International Space Station, interrogating the value of human achievement against cosmic immensity. While the novel acknowledges that technological ingenuity enables orbital survival to a considerable extent, it simultaneously reveals that grandiose ambition pales beside the modest achievement of collective witness2 and planetary care. The author therefore challenges her twenty-first century readership to appreciate human accomplishment through humble custodianship rather than hubristic conquest3, cherishing the fragile terrestrial bonds that sustain mortal life.

Harvey initially presents orbital elevation as the zenith of technological mastery, yet exposes4 how cosmic scale strips away the illusion of triumphant human achievement to foster humble solidarity. Suspended in space with the collective consciousness "they are so together" yet "so alone", the crew coalesces into a unified psychological entity, as the isolating sublimity of the void replaces individual ambition with a yearning for terrestrial belonging. Centring on the fragmented "trail of gunpowder" reflecting temporal distortion as a "milky cover" obscures the "siphoning eye", the roving third person narration drains the astronauts and cosmonauts of triumphant mastery5, their perspectives consumed by boundless immensity. Thus, resisting erasure, Shaun studies his "postcard of Las Meninas", reflective of mere bystanders mirroring a "privileged anxious view" of "mother Earth", which humbles human endeavour into subdued contemplation. In doing so, the novel articulates the duality between beauty and burden, her readership alongside the crew witnessing Earth's ecological transformation while recognising that technological triumphs cannot protect the life flourishing below. This humbled mastery narrows into exposed vulnerability6 when Chie and Pietro confront personal loss and planetary catastrophe. Through Chie's anguished chant of "mother mother mother mother"7, Harvey captures the introspective weight of individual bereavement, inviting readers to echo the mantra and exposing how orbital prestige offers no immunity against mortality. Examining her sorrow amidst a "muscling and spiralling" typhoon, the narration reveals humanity's impotence against natural catastrophe, dismantling illusions of supremacy. This enforces the "collision of worlds" whereby the author dismantles the distance between fisherman and astronaut who both "lie low hopelessly"8, serving as a microcosm for our limited agency when Pietro's fixation on the "particular fisherman and his family" amidst the storm's "building magnificence" overshadows engineering feats. Hence, the oxymoronic enchantment of an "unearthly watery light" magnifies the "tethers of biological life" within "the chapel['s]" sanctified shelter, where preserving kinship transcends the "piddling speck" of our existence as humanity's truest accomplishment. Through cosmic exposure and terrestrial storm, Harvey reveals that genuine achievement lies in shared vulnerability rather than conquest9.

Want to tailor your essays to your teachers while preparing for the VCE exam?

Our VCE English tutors show you how to adapt your writing for your school's markers while getting exam ready, using the exact techniques annotated here. Join the waitlist to secure a spot.

Join the waitlist