Artin Education
Annotated Sample Essay Text Response AI Assisted

Orbital argues that art comprehends what science alone cannot.' Discuss.

A high-scoring Text Response essay, annotated

Orbital · Samantha Harvey

A high-scoring Text Response essay on Samantha Harvey's Orbital, annotated to demonstrate analytical craft and essay structure.

Essay prompt

Orbital argues that art comprehends what science alone cannot.' Discuss.

VCE EnglishOrbitalSamantha HarveyText Response

Published in 2023 amidst an accelerating climate crisis and the irreversible transformations of the Anthropocene, Samantha Harvey's novel Orbital surveys the earth from the International Space Station, exploring how empirical observation is enriched by the perceptive lens of art.1 While Harvey initially positions the orbital perspective as a triumph of scientific measurement, she ultimately reveals that art and aesthetic wonder cultivate a comprehension of the planet's splendour that mechanical data alone cannot capture.2 Harvey therefore challenges her contemporary audience to recognise awe as a vital mode of knowledge, urging readers to embrace an artistic reverence for the fragile natural world.3

Harvey initially presents the orbital vantage point as an isolating exposure to cosmic scale, yet reveals that aesthetic witness recasts this sublimity into a collective understanding of earthly fragility.4 Suspended in liminal space, Harvey's illustration of the collective consciousness "they are so together"5 yet "so alone" coalesces the crew into a unified psychological entity, revealing how the isolating sublimity of the void cultivates an artistic reverence that strict measurement lacks. To resist cosmic erasure, readers bear witness to Shaun's "postcard of Las Meninas," its bystanders mirroring the crew's "privileged anxious view" of "mother Earth" as observation becomes an act of artistic interpretation. This visual canvas frames the duality of beauty and burden, allowing Harvey's readership alongside the crew to confront Earth's Anthropocene transformation through a perceptive lens that scientific data cannot achieve. Against this distancing awe, Pietro's attention to the storm restores an intimate scale, reframing the crew's watchfulness as a perceptive meditation on human limits.6 Through Chie's anguished chant of "mother mother mother mother"7, the narration captures the introspective weight of private grief, translating raw emotional data into a lyrical rhythm that strict empiricism ignores. Yet the roving third-person narration's discernment of the storm's "building magnificence", held alongside Pietro's fixation on the "particular fisherman and his family", transmutes the typhoon's immensity into a visual microcosm of shared vulnerability. Hence, the oxymoronic enchantment of an "unearthly watery light" magnifies the "tethers of biological life" within "the chapel['s]" sanctified shelter, capturing a splendour that transcends the "piddling speck" of physical existence to celebrate human endurance through art. Through this woven visual witness, Harvey establishes aesthetic wonder as a vital lens for understanding existence. Harvey initially presents the orbital vantage point as an isolating exposure to cosmic scale, yet reveals that aesthetic witness recasts this sublimity into a collective understanding of earthly fragility.8

Want to tailor your essays to your teachers while preparing for the VCE exam?

Our VCE English tutors show you how to adapt your writing for your school's markers while getting exam ready, using the exact techniques annotated here. Join the waitlist to secure a spot.

Join the waitlist