Artin Education
Annotated Sample Essay Text Response AI Assisted

“...we'll devise a planetary flag because that's a thing we lacked on earth...!” ‘Harvey presents a shared sense of humanity often overlooked on Earth.’ Discuss.

A high-scoring Text Response essay, annotated

Orbital · Samantha Harvey

A high-scoring Text Response essay on Samantha Harvey's Orbital, annotated to demonstrate analytical craft and essay structure.

Essay prompt

“...we'll devise a planetary flag because that's a thing we lacked on earth...!” ‘Harvey presents a shared sense of humanity often overlooked on Earth.’ Discuss.

VCE EnglishOrbitalSamantha HarveyText Response

Composed amidst pandemic lockdowns and awarded the 2024 Booker Prize1, Samantha Harvey's 2023 novel Orbital surveys sixteen circuits of a planet altered by the Anthropocene, questioning how terrestrial divisions obscure our fundamental interconnectedness. While the novel concedes that national rivalries and geographical boundaries routinely fracture human belonging on Earth, it demonstrates that the vantage point of low Earth orbit dissolves these artificial barriers2 to expose an inescapable collective kinship. Harvey therefore challenges her contemporary readership to abandon the terrestrial illusion of separation3, inviting her modern audience to cultivate the unified solidarity that sustains mortal existence upon an imperilled world.

Harvey initially presents orbital withdrawal as a rupture from terrestrial belonging4, yet reveals that distance strips away earthly divisions to expose a collective interdependence often neglected below. Suspended with the collective consciousness "they are so together" yet "so alone", the crew forms a unified psychological entity as the isolating sublimity of the void forges an interdependence often obscured on the fractured surface below. That cohesion falters as the fragmented "trail of gunpowder" reflecting temporal distortion projects a "milky cover" over the "siphoning eye", the roving third person narration draining the astronauts and cosmonauts of separate perspectives5 until solitary viewpoints dissolve before space's immensity. Resisting cosmic erasure, Shaun studies his "postcard of Las Meninas6" where mere bystanders mirror the crew's "privileged anxious view" of "mother Earth", uniting observer and observed in an undivided vigil across distance. Consequently, the novel's orbital perspective converts the tension between beauty and burden into a shared humanity, as Harvey's readership and the crew witness the planet's transformation while bound to the terrestrial kinship neglected below. This collective vigil narrows into intimate solidarity7 when Chie confronts her mother's death alongside Pietro's fear for a distant family. Through Chie's anguished chant "mother mother mother mother8" the author captures the weight of solitary bereavement, inviting readers to echo the mantra in their own minds and transforming private mourning into communal empathy. This enforces a "collision of worlds" that dismantles the distance between fisherman and astronaut who both "lie low hopelessly", Pietro's concern for a "particular fisherman and his family" amidst the storm's "building magnificence" serving as a microcosm of human vulnerability. Hence, the oxymoronic enchantment of an "unearthly watery light" from the typhoon magnifies the "tethers of biological life" within "the chapel['s]" sanctified shelter, where preserving kinship transcends the "piddling speck" of existence into a shared humanity seldom recognised on Earth. Harvey's convergence of orbital watching and terrestrial mourning exposes an unbroken human kinship that earthly borders routinely obscure9.

Want to tailor your essays to your teachers while preparing for the VCE exam?

Our VCE English tutors show you how to adapt your writing for your school's markers while getting exam ready, using the exact techniques annotated here. Join the waitlist to secure a spot.

Join the waitlist