"the hand of science" 'In Orbital, technology is both saviour and cage.' Discuss.
A high-scoring Text Response essay, annotated
A high-scoring Text Response essay on Samantha Harvey's Orbital, annotated to demonstrate analytical craft and essay structure.
"the hand of science" 'In Orbital, technology is both saviour and cage.' Discuss.
Published in 2023 as the International Space Station nears the end of its working life, Samantha Harvey's novel Orbital contemplates humanity's reliance on machinery while circling a planet irreversibly scarred by the Anthropocene.1 While the spacecraft initially appears to confine the astronauts within an artificial cage suspended against the void, the text reveals that this intense technological dependence acts as a vital saviour, transforming mechanical restriction into a sustaining sanctuary.2 Harvey therefore challenges her modern audience to recognise that artificial confinement does not inherently diminish human vitality, urging contemporary readers to view the mechanisms that preserve life as extensions of shared resilience rather than mere boundaries of existence.3
Harvey initially presents the orbital environment as a hostile expanse that demands technological shelter, yet exposes how this artificial boundary functions as a necessary cage that clarifies humanity's vulnerability.4 Suspended within liminality between the void and their mechanical lifeline, the crew's collective consciousness of "they are so together"5 yet "so alone" coalesces into a unified psychological entity, revealing how the isolating vastness of space forges an interdependence bound by artificial confinement. That unity nonetheless splinters as the fragmented "trail of gunpowder" reflecting their temporal distortion projects a "milky cover" obscuring their "siphoning eye", draining the astronauts and cosmonauts of their perspectives that dissipate before an immensity hostile to human survival. To withstand this cosmic threat, readers bear witness to Shaun's "postcard of Las Meninas", its painted bystanders mirroring the crew's "privileged anxious view" of "mother Earth", recasting their observation as an act of reliance on their metal bounds. This recognition of the void's threat narrows into an intimate confrontation with mortality when Chie receives news of her mother's death, exposing the emotional limits of their mechanical shelter.6 Through Chie's anguished chant of "mother mother mother mother"7, the roving narration captures the introspective weight of individual mourning that invites readers to echo the mantra, exposing how isolation within the ship magnifies private grief. Yet the storm's "building magnificence" held alongside Pietro's fixation on the "particular fisherman and his family" transforms the typhoon's immensity into a meditation on shared vulnerability, a microcosm of frailty that their orbiting perimeter cannot fully shield. Hence, the oxymoronic enchantment of an "unearthly watery light" magnifies the "tethers of biological life" as the station's "chapel['s]" sanctified nature is illuminated, whereby the collective preservation of earthly bonds translates restrictive borders into a celebration of generational shelter. Through these paired moments, Harvey establishes that the station's confinement acts simultaneously as isolating cage and vital saviour. Harvey initially presents the orbital environment as a hostile expanse that demands technological shelter, yet exposes how this artificial boundary functions as a necessary cage that clarifies humanity's vulnerability.8
Want to tailor your essays to your teachers while preparing for the VCE exam?
Our VCE English tutors show you how to adapt your writing for your school's markers while getting exam ready, using the exact techniques annotated here. Join the waitlist to secure a spot.
Join the waitlist